Is Beauty Pie worth it? A beauty junkie investigates…

Find out exactly what we think...

Is Beauty Pie worth it?

by Georgia Scott |
Updated on

Since the likes of Netflix, Spotify and Amazon Prime became the norm within our households, allowing us to binge-watch the latest releases as and when we please, we've started to explore what else we could subscribe to in order to make life easier and more exciting.

It makes sense, then (if you ask us), to have one of life's other great pleasures on demand, too - beauty products. If you've already found love with a beauty subscription box, you might be toying with the idea of signing up for a beauty subscription service, like Beauty Pie. But are the products any good, and is it worth it?

To save you the hassle, time and money, we've put some of Beauty Pie's most popular products to the test to help you decide if you want to part with your hard-earned cash.

What is Beauty Pie?

Beauty Pie is a unique way to shop for luxury beauty products without the expensive price tag. You can find a wide range of luxury products including skincare, make-up, haircare and candles at members-only prices.

If you're a beauty junkie - this could be the answer to all of your problems.

What is the concept behind Beauty Pie?

'Overpaying is officially over.'

Beauty Pie is the first female-founded, luxury buyers club where you pay an annual membership fee to access luxury skincare, cosmetics, hair care, candles, supplements and apparel at affordable prices. The scheme is designed to cut out the middle man and buy high-quality products directly from development labs across the world.

How much does a Beauty Pie membership cost?

The annual membership costs £59, working out at just under £5 a month. You can trial Beauty Pie free for 60 days, too.

Now, let's get to the juicy stuff. We've tried and tested Beauty Pie's best-sellers to save you time in deciding which products to try first (and which to avoid).

SHOP: The Best Beauty Pie Products: Reviewed

Beauty Pie Triple Hyaluronic Acid Lipopeptide SerumBeauty Pie
Price: $24 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

Hyaluronic acid is an essential skincare ingredient in any daily routine. Introducing a hyaluronic acid serum can transform the skin to look dewy and plump whilst fighting any signs of ageing. It visibly improves the condition of the skin on the first application and continues to maintain moisture with regular use. Hyaluronic acid acts as a moisture magnet and can draw 1000 times its weight in water and be used by all skin types.

Things we love:
• Contains three different weights of hyaluronic molecules to treat multiple layers of the skin.
• Promotes long-lasting hydration.

Our review: "A lightweight yet moisturising serum that sits comfortably under make-up. My skin felt instantly soothed, soft and hydrated after the first application. It's slightly scented, which may aggravate those who prefer to use fragrance-free skincare."

Customer review: "On my second bottle of Triple Hyaluronic Acid, an excellent product, I suffer with really dry Eczema on my neck face and hands, I use this every morning and night after cleansing religiously to prevent any dryness which can cause me to scratch, so pleased I found beauty pie, products are amazing value for money, I would definitely recommend."

Beauty Pie Featherlight UVA/UVB SPF 50Beauty Pie
Price: $15 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

Finding a daily SPF that feels lightweight and doesn't leave a white cast can typically be difficult. However, the Featherlight SPF is a game-changer. Prime and protect the skin without feeling or seeing any residue on the skin or under make-up. Apply after moisturiser and before make-up for the ultimate protected base.

Things we love:
• Non-comedogenic - doesn't clog pores.
• UVA and UVB protection.
• Doesn't leave a white cast.

Our review: "It's always tricky to discover an SPF that doesn't leave a white cast on the skin and this one glides on top of my moisturiser. The packaging is ideal for your make-up and travelling."

Customer review: "I was dubious about using this SPF - having combination oily acne prone skin, products like this often serve to clog my pores and leave me with breakouts and a very greasy looking face. Not this one! It really is featherlight and soaks into the skin easily and doesn't leave any residue on the skin. It also hasn't contributed to any breakouts either since using it - result!"

Beauty Pie Youthbomb Radiance Concentrate SerumBeauty Pie
Price: $44 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

Treat your skin with a blend of 15 different active ingredients designed to hydrate, firm, resurface and brighten. If you're looking for a product to give your skin a shot of hydration but create that dewy look we all crave, this is a serum you should consider trying. This treatment is full of proteins and hydrators and can be used on a clean face every morning and evening. The lightweight formula melts into the skin in seconds and the handy pipette allows you to control how much product you apply.

Things we love:
• Youthbomb is full of proteins, peptides and hydrators.
• Easy-to-use dropper allows you to tailor how much product you want to use.

Our review: "I love trying serums, especially those that promise to brighten and add a glow. Youthbomb makes my skin look radiant and sits comfortably under moisturiser and SPF. A serum that claims it can create the look of a facelift is a bold claim, but I feel like it boosts luminosity and improves the texture of my skin."

Customer review: "I’m onto my second bottle of this and I love it! It has firmed and tightened my skin, left it smooth and has helped with hydration. The best part is that it has completely lifted my upper eyelids and got rid of my slightly hooded eyes!"

Beauty Pie Japanfusion Genius Lift ElixirBeauty Pie
Price: $14 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

This elixir is made with a gentle blend of ingredients whenever your skin needs an extra boost. Your skin might be dry, dehydrated or needs a bit of TLC and this elixir soothes and adds a dewy glow - much needed as we enter into the colder months. Add a couple of drops into your serum or moisturiser or apply directly onto the skin.

Things we love:
• Features grape and jabara extract an antioxidant from the Japanese Citrus Fruit, rich in vitamin C
• Polynesian seaweed (works like hyaluronic acid to draw moisture to the skin - result)

Our review: "This Elixir looks great under make-up if you love your skin looking healthy and dewy without using any sparkly highlighter. It works as a glowing primer but continues to care for your skin. Skin looks brighter and feels firm after one use. The texture is quite emollient, which could suit a drier skin type."

Customer review: "What a fantastic serum. Smooths my fine lines and wrinkles. Firm's my skin like a dream. Forget the super pricey brands. This stuff works. I am almost 50 years old and I have used a lot of "high-end" brands and hands down Beauty Pie blows them all out of the water!"

Beauty Pie Superluminous Under-Eye GeniusBeauty Pie
Price: $12 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

Don't sleep on this product - If you are familiar with the Becca Under-Eye Brightener that has since been discontinued, this product is one to grab your attention. Finding an under-eye corrector that instantly improves the appearance of any discolouration is key if you like a brighter complexion. This skincare/make-up hybrid treats your under-eye concerns whilst leaving your under-eyes looking luminous. The pink undertone naturally colour corrects any darkness to create an even canvas before concealer. The creamy formula sits evenly under concealer and naturally brightens without looking cakey.

Details: Available in two shades; light-medium and medium-dark.

Things we love:
• Vitamin E moisturises and soothes.
• Fatty acids smooth fine lines.

Our review: "This product works so well on my dark circles and I'm impressed with the texture. I applied the corrector with my ring finger to blend under the eyes with ease. It sits under my foundation and concealer comfortably, without creasing."

Customer review: "What an amazing brightened this product is. I don’t always need concealer, this just brightens up my face. So glad I purchased it after wondering a long time about it."

Beauty Pie Super Healthy Skin Deluxe Body Moisture CrèmeBeauty Pie
Price: $19 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

Treat your skin with lots of moisture, especially as we come into the winter months. This body moisturiser feels light, whipped and nourishing on the skin but most importantly smells like a dream. This moisture cream comes in a travel-friendly jar guaranteed to avoid any spillage as you travel.

Things we love:
• Hibiscus flower oil
• Shea butter
• Meadowfoam oils
• Geranium scent that smells fresh and luxurious.

Our review: "If you love a body cream with a whipped texture, this product is a winner. It has a really light, pleasant scent that lingers throughout the day and keeps the skin feeling moisturised."

Customer review: "I have been using this consistently for a year and I look forward to opening the lid every morning. The texture is light and melts right into my skin and the fragrance has become my favourite."

Beauty Pie Sheer Tinted Oil-Free SPF20Beauty Pie
Price: $12.50 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

A great everyday base to even out the complexion, particularly great if your skin suffers from additional redness or discolouration. This sheer, tinted moisturiser protects the skin from any sun damage and adds a soft-focus glow - ideal for everyday wear. Apply like your typical moisturiser or blend into the skin with your favourite make-up brush.

Things we love:
• Available in eight shades
• Jojoba esters and liquorice extract to moisturise.

Customer review: "A beautiful light non-greasy tinted foundation. This product definitely surprised me as I've never come across such a beautiful realistic foundation. Makes me look 20 years younger, so I'm delighted."

Beauty Pie Super Healthy Hair Elastic-Repair Hair TreatmentBeauty Pie
Price: $12 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

If your hair needs some love after lots of heat styling or hair dying, this product will bring some life back to your strands. This treatment is designed to strengthen the natural cuticles in the hair to repair any damage. It can easily be added to your existing shampoo and conditioner routine. Once you've rinsed your hair thoroughly, apply the treatment evenly and leave for three to five minutes. For the best results, use it once or twice a week depending on the condition of your hair.

Things we love:
• Amino acids are derived from quinoa to protect the hair and enhance colour.
• Shea butter to moisturise and protect.

Customer review: "Amazing product. Now hooked on this, it's my second tube. Took a couple of uses to notice a difference and get the right amount of product after so hair wasn't weighed down. I used it twice a week when I use a scalp scrub to give my hair some TLC. It leaves ends smoother and I've not needed to visit the hairdresser as regularly. Leaves hair smooth, shiny and bouncy. Love!"

Beauty Pie Japanfusion Pure Transforming CleanserBeauty Pie
Price: $10 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

A super moisturising cleanser made to remove every stitch of make-up and impurities. This gel cleanser transforms into a milky oil once mixed with water to break down make-up without causing any irritation. Apply onto dry skin to break down any make-up build-up and remove with warm water or a hot cloth.

Things we love:
• Vitamin E to soothe
• Jabara extract is an antioxidant derived from the Japanese citrus fruit, rich in vitamin C

Our review: "As soon as you've applied the cleanser, you feel your make-up melting away. The cleanser breaks down any make-up and skincare until you add water where it slightly emulsifiers, to leave the skin feeling squeaky clean."

Customer review: "I’ve tried A LOT of cleansers and always come back to this one. It feels luxurious to use, breaks down make-up effectively and leaves my skin clean and clear but still hydrated. The tube makes it super easy."

Beauty Pie Super Healthy Skin Ultimate Anti-Aging CreamBeauty Pie
Price: $19 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

This plumping cream works well as an everyday face moisturiser for those who love a rich, creamy texture. Full of ingredients all designed to work in harmony to lift, brighten and hydrate. It's a great starting point if you are wanting to get into anti-ageing skincare without diving straight into retinol. This cream can be used by those with all skin types, including sensitive skin and is suitable to wear during the day as a great base for make-up or as a luxurious evening treatment.

Things we love:
• Hyaluronic acid and plant bio-actives to plump and hydrate

Our review: "If you love a rich cream, this is the moisturiser for you. My skin felt instantly moisturised and plumped after one use, and it makes a great base for make-up. You can also apply it as a night moisturiser to wake up with super plump skin that firms over time."

Customer review: "I’ve been using this moisturiser for 18 months. It’s brilliant and lasts for ages. I use it alongside the anti ageing eye cream and I use the youth bomb serum. I’m so glad I found Beauty Pie."

Beauty Pie Collagen Super PowderBeauty Pie
Price: $29 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

Maintaining healthy skin, hair and nails can start from within and introducing this super powder to your smoothie or water can make all the difference. Having a diligent skincare routine is always key but incorporating a powder supplement into your diet can hugely benefit the skin. We recommend consulting a GP if you're taking any prescribed medication before starting the supplement.

Ingredients we love:
• Vitamin C
• Marine collagen
• Biotin
• Hyaluronic acid
• Natural flavourings
• Organic tremella mushroom powder

Customer review: "There have been many Beauty Pie products that I love but none as much as this collagen. I've been taking it for a couple of months and have seen a DRAMATIC improvement in my skin, especially my face and neck. I've never had a beauty product that has given me such noticeable results. I take it each morning on an empty stomach mixed into warm water. Super easy and mild slightly sweet flavour. LOVE IT!"

Beauty Pie SuperdropsBeauty Pie
Price: $15 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

A super soothing treatment designed to calm and re-energise the skin. Reach for this product whenever your skin is feeling out of sorts, it's decided to break out or you want to get rid of any unwanted texture. Apply under your usual serum and moisturiser for an added boost to your skincare routine.

Things we love:
• Niacinamide - derived from vitamin B3, strengthens the skin's natural barrier and calms any inflammation

Our review: "A niacinamide serum is essential in any skincare routine and works well to soothe and calm the skin. The texture is very lightweight and settles into the skin in seconds."

Customer review: "My favourite Beauty Pie product, these really are Superdrops! Since using twice a day I've not had a single spot or blemish, my skin is radiant and I am so delighted with the results from these drops."

Beauty Pie Super RetinolBeauty Pie
Price: $18.50 (with a membership)

www.beautypie.com

You might've heard of retinol and felt too scared to try it, but this one is a great starting point. Although this retinol is a 1 per cent strength - the strongest percentage you can buy over the counter, you can decide where you want to apply the product and how much to use. This product is made with slow-release retinol to gradually introduce the skin to the effects of retinol without seeing a sudden reaction. Apply like you would your usual night-time moisturiser and leave it on the skin for 10-15 minutes before following with any further skincare, should you need it. Ensure you wear SPF throughout the day following use.

What is retinol?
Derived from vitamin A, retinol is the ultimate anti-ageing ingredient to encourage a quicker cell turnover and bring new cells to the surface. It's designed to reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles and improve the appearance of any discolouration or pigmentation on the surface of the skin.

Things we love:
• Super Retinol is formulated with vitamins C and E, shea butter, ferulic and hyaluronic acid to help protect, soothe, brighten and hydrate the skin as it resurfaces.
• Great packaging that keeps the product stable and free from oxygen and sunlight.

Our review: "I used to be sceptical about using retinol as my skin is super sensitive, but this product is more of a night-time treatment that leaves the skin looking glowing and feeling moisturised when I wake up. You can apply a night oil or cream after applying Super Retinol, but it's not necessary as it's hydrating on its own."

Customer review: "So happy I purchased this although I was apprehensive at first trying a different retinol I'm glad I did, I've noticed an improvement in the texture of my skin it's much softer and smoother."

FAQs

Is a Beauty Pie subscription worth it?

If you regularly spend money on new beauty products, you like to experiment with different beauty products or are still trying to find your perfect skincare routine - Beauty Pie is a great subscription service for you to try. With 30 days to get to grips with how it all works, it's a no-brainer.

Who founded Beauty Pie?

Marcia Kilgore, an entrepreneur with 30 years of experience, is commonly known for launching Soap & Glory.

Can you try Beauty Pie before signing up?

Yes, you can try Beauty Pie free for 30 days before continuing with the yearly subscription.

Georgia Scott is a beauty and fashion product writer writing across brands such as heat, Closer, Grazia and Yours specialising in all things lifestyle and trending. Before starting at Bauer, Georgia completed her degree in Journalism at University and worked as a retail beauty advisor and make-up artist.

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us