Bake Off fans slam Paul Hollywood for axing Henry Bird after pastry showstopper

Fans aren’t happy with the judges’ decision to send home Henry

Paul Hollywood

by Maria Mellor |
Updated on

Paul Hollywood has faced the fury of fans after sending home Bake Off favourite, Henry Bird.

The 20-year-old student attempted a four-tier pie as the final showstopper. However both flavour and execution failed to impress the judges.

Fans were left furious, with one saying: “Absolutely outrageous. For the judges to say that Henry’s showstopper was ‘pies stacked on top of each other’ but then to praise Steph for doing exactly the same thing WITH A CAKE STAND is ridiculous.”

Check out: Great British Bake Off - everything you need to know

Gallery

Great British Bake Off: Everything you need to know - Slider

1. Anyone can apply for Bake Off1 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

1. Anyone can apply for Bake Off

Except professional bakers or chefs!Applications are open to any UK resident over the age of 16. However they cannot make their main source of income from commercial baking and entrants can't have worked as a professional chef or baker at any point. Plus, applicants cannot have acquired any professional catering qualifications in the last ten years

2. The GBBO application form is l-o-n-g2 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

2. The GBBO application form is l-o-n-g

It's seven pages long, asks a LOT of questions, and demands you reveal the truth about your previous successes and failures in the kitchen.You can find it here.

3. The Great British Bake Off application process doesnu2019t stop there!3 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

3. The Great British Bake Off application process doesn’t stop there!

If they like what they see on your application form, a researcher will call you and give you a 45 minute interview over the phone.Then, if you pass THAT test, they'll have you whip up two baked treats, bring them to London, have an interview with a producer, and go through a screen test.Think you're done? Nope!You then have to try out a Technical Challenge set by the GBBO judges - in front of the camera. They also ask that you bring another bake along (presumably the producers are taste testing these / big fans of cake).If you're still in the running, you'll then be interviewed by the show's psychologist to make sure they can handle the pressure of filming.

4. GBBO filming is intense4 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

4. GBBO filming is intense

The show is filmed over a 10-week period between April and June, with contestants spending up to 16 hours a day filming.They manage to package up a whole session of baking into one hour, which means that a lot of it ends up on the cutting room floor.

5... but at least itu2019s contained to weekends5 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

5... but at least it’s contained to weekends

That's right, contestants only do their GBBO stuff on weekends, which means that they can keep working their normal 9-to-5 jobs in the week.However they are picked up from their hotels at 9am each Saturday and Sunday morning, to ensure they get as much filming time in as possible.No rest for the wicked, eh?

6. GBBO contestants donu2019t do the washing up themselves6 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

6. GBBO contestants don’t do the washing up themselves

There's no dishwasher on Bake Off, because the noise would disrupt filming. Instead, home economists spend 160 hours washing up everything by hand. We hope they all get given a free hand lotion each…

7. GBBO contestants pay for ingredients themselves7 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

7. GBBO contestants pay for ingredients themselves

Yup, that's right; they only get their ingredients provided when they reach the finals - which makes things pretty expensive. Particularly as they use between 12-20 ingredients per bake.

8. A lot of people are involved in the production of GBBO8 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

8. A lot of people are involved in the production of GBBO

There are around 50 crew members on set - and, yes, they all get to tuck into the cakes and goodies after the judges give their verdict.

9. GBBO contestants are encouraged to become friends9 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

9. GBBO contestants are encouraged to become friends

Producers take all contestants out for dinner together on the first night, and they usually become good pals over time; they often stay at the same hotel, so dinners and drinks and socialising become pretty regular.Which means that, yes, they really DO mean it when they say they're happy for the overall winner - they're pretty much all besties by that point!

10. They make more cakes than youu2019d ever dreamed of10 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

10. They make more cakes than you’d ever dreamed of

They bake a Victoria Sponge in each oven every single morning of filming, to make sure everything is ship-shape and ready to go. We imagine everyone gets a bit sick of tucking into that particular type of cake come the end of filming!

11. The show is LITERALLY based on village fetes11 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

11. The show is LITERALLY based on village fetes

That's right; Anna Beattie, the show's creator, really believed that village fete baking competitions would suit TV. Anna, judging by the viewing figures, was 100% correct!

12. Mel and Sue recommended Mary Berry12 of 17
CREDIT: Getty Images

12. Mel and Sue recommended Mary Berry

The duo were approached to present the show together - and they were quick to suggest that Mary Berry should be a judge back when GBBO was on BBC One. The show moved to Channel 4 in 2017 without Mary Berry.

13. Itu2019s not a disaster if someone forgets an ingredient13 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

13. It’s not a disaster if someone forgets an ingredient

In fact, producers are well and truly prepared if this happens; they have a runner on standby at a local supermarket every morning in case a contestant realises overnight that they've forgotten an ingredient.

14. Oven time is crucial14 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

14. Oven time is crucial

So much so that contestants aren't allowed to put anything in - or take anything out of - the oven without flagging a producer down first. They want to make sure that they have a camera on standby to film those big baking moments.

15. The Bake Off challenges are NOT surprises15 of 17
CREDIT: Getty Images

15. The Bake Off challenges are NOT surprises

If you make it through to the Bake Off finals, you will be told what the challenges are going to be - and you'll have to submit your recipes for approval. Eep! No pressure, eh?

16. Mary Berry and Paul Hollywood were off limits16 of 17
CREDIT: Channel 4

16. Mary Berry and Paul Hollywood were off limits

Back when the show was on BBC One, they prefered to keep things professional with contestants, and wouldn't usually speak to them outside of the Bake Off tent.

17. u2026 but Mel and Sue weren't17 of 17
CREDIT: BBC

17. … but Mel and Sue weren't

The duo were happy to chat to contestants away from the cameras - and Sue even said that she likes to stay in touch with them via email once the show is all over. N'aww.

Paul Hollywood
©Getty

Prue Leith felt that the design fell flat, calling it ‘unimaginative’, and Paul called the meat filling ‘bone dry’, saying that all the moisture had escaped through the top.

Henry made chocolate and pecan pies as a sweet option in his tower, however Paul said it tasted more like a mince pie.

Henry asked hopefully whether Paul liked Christmas, but the 53-year-old replied simply: “Humbug.”

Henry Bird
©Channel 4

“Paul definitely woke up on the wrong side of the bed. He was unnecessarily nasty tonight,” wrote one irritated fan, while another said, “It's Paul's judging skills that's dry! No need to watch it anymore, sorry to see you go Henry.”

WATCH: X Factor's Samira walks off set as The Love Islander's battle it out in 'The Reality Check Quiz'

READ MORE

Two Pints of Lager and a Packet of Crisps cast - where are they now?

X Factor: Celebrity's Brendan Cole forced to apologise after SHADY comment

Strictly fans horrified as Zoe Ball called 'FAT' by professional dancer

Henry impressed the judges in the signature challenge with his crab, new potato and tomato tarte tatin. However, he fell short in the Moroccan pie technical challenge, coming last out of the five remaining bakers.

Despite his defeat, Henry remained unruffled as he said his goodbyes, saying: “It’s been a pleasure, darling.”

While there are many people who are angry at the judges’ decision, there are some fans who think it was fair. One fan said: “Love Henry but he deserved to go home.

Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website, we never allow this to influence product selections - read why you should trust us