Under eye concealers reviews: the best for fair skin

For when your skin needs a little pick-me-up.

Concealers

by Emma Dodds |
Updated on

Which are the best concealers for hiding dark circles under the eyes? We've tried and tested eight concealers from the high street to see which ones stand up...

Concealers can often be the most important thing in a makeup bag. No matter what your age is or how lucky you got with genes, EVERYONE gets dark circles from time to time.

That aside, sometimes you simply don't have time to sit in front of your makeup mirror for half an hour doing your face - sometimes, you need a dab of concealer under the eyes and a lick of mascara to get you out of the door.

High street concealers
We tried Charlotte Tilbury, Max Factor, Rimmel, CYO, Barry M, Maybelline, No7 and Benefit ©Closer Online

But is it worth spending more on a concealer, or are you better off just getting a cheap one? And are crayons better, or do you need a liquid one with a brush on the end? So many questions!

That's where we come in. We've tried and tested eight concealers currently available on the high street to see which ones are the best for a quick dab and a rush out the door...

We may earn a commission for purchases made through our links

Gallery

CLOSER concealer review

Maybelline Eraser Eye Concealer, 00 Ivory1 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

Maybelline Eraser Eye Concealer, 00 Ivory

Ease of use: This was SO EASY to apply – just twist a couple of times, blob under your eyes and tap with your fingers… And you're ready to go! Feel/Coverage: I could tell I had makeup on, but it didn't feel heavy or obvious at all. It also gave me a slight glow around the eyes, which is always a plus.Wear: It lasted all day, thank goodness!Comments: Aside from being easy, nice to the touch AND colour-matching, it was also super easy to take off with micellar water and a cotton pad. Another big plus is that there are now 12 shades available. Thumbs up!5/5amazon.co.uk

Rimmel Match Perfection Skin Tone Adapting Concealer, 010 Porcelain2 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

Rimmel Match Perfection Skin Tone Adapting Concealer, 010 Porcelain

Ease of use: This one has a little brush on the end, but instead of a twist bottom, you squeeze the tube to make the concealer appear. Unfortunately, it was a little hard to control and I ended up squeezing too much out. It wasn't ideal!Feel/Coverage: This concealer is much heavier than I would personally normally wear. If you prefer a heavier coverage then great, but blending in took a lot longer and this could damage the sensitive and delicate skin around your eyes if used every day. It also didn't offer that glow that the other products did, which is fine if you're going to build on it with foundation – but for a quick dash out the door it's not the greatest.Wear: It did last all day but my eyes did look slightly dull.Comments: This would be great for someone with very dark circles who has time to blend and build, but if you're running out the door you might not have time. There are also only six shades, which may not suit everyone.2/5amazon.co.uk

Charlotte Tilbury The Retoucher, 1 Fair3 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

Charlotte Tilbury The Retoucher, 1 Fair

Ease of use: The Retoucher also has a brush on the end with the liquid inside, which you twist to get out. The brush was super soft and very easy to apply directly onto the skin, although I prefer to dab it on the back of my hand first. Apart from the initial twist, it didn't take long at all for the product to appear.Feel/Coverage: This was so light, I could barely tell I had makeup on. The only problem with that is that I tend to touch my face a lot, so it could come off throughout the day. It too had a slight glow!Wear: It lasted all day, but it wasn't as strong towards the end of the day – but that's my own fault!Comments: I love Charlotte Tilbury makeup so it's no surprise to me that The Retoucher is FANTASTIC. It was also really easy to take off at the end of the day. There are 10 shades, which is quite inclusive.5/5cultbeauty.co.uk

CYO Brush With Brilliance Highlighting Concealer, Fair4 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

CYO Brush With Brilliance Highlighting Concealer, Fair

Ease of use: Yet another brush! This time, it had a clicky bottom so the amount was quite easy to control.Feel/Coverage: Again, it was a little heavier than I'd normally go for – more of a cream – but once it was on it didn't feel super heavy. Wear: It didn't quite last all day but it still masked my dark circles.Comments: I did really like this concealer, and at such a low price, you can't really go wrong. A slight issue for me was that the "Fair" colour was ever so slightly yellow on my skin, so it wouldn't exactly work if I wanted to just dab a bit of concealer on, brush a bit of mascara on my lashes and run out the door. However, it would work just fine on other areas of my face after using foundation. There are only three shades, which might not suit everyone.3/5boots.com

Max Factor Mastertouch All Day Concealer, 303 Ivory5 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

Max Factor Mastertouch All Day Concealer, 303 Ivory

Ease of use: Now this is a very innovative idea – it's a sort of slanted sponge and the concealer comes through a hole once twisted at the bottom. It was lovely and soft, and so easy to put on. I unfortunately got a little over zealous and squeezed out too much on one eye. Less is more, people!Feel/Coverage: It looks quite thick when it comes out, but it glides onto your under-eye very smoothly thanks to the brush. It didn't feel really heavy at all, but it did look a little dry and I do have dry skin, so I'm not sure it would work for me personally long-term. It's a shame though as I do really like it.Wear: It does what it says on the tin – lasted all day!Comments: It really is a shame that it didn't quite settle in right on my skin as it is a lovely product. You can tell that Max Factor have really thought it through, it's a slick bit of kit. However, this product is let down by the fact that there are only three shades and they're all very similar light colours, which isn't very all-encompassing.4/5amazon.co.uk

Barry M All Night Long Full Coverage Concealer, 02 Oatmeal6 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

Barry M All Night Long Full Coverage Concealer, 02 Oatmeal

Ease of use: The wand is slanted which makes it so easy to apply directly onto your under-eye and lids. There's a stopper just inside the rim which stops you from getting too much product out in one go.Feel/Coverage: It's DEFINITELY a full coverage – but it didn't feel heavy. It dries super quickly, which is very handy if you're in a rush. It felt ever so slightly chalky after first putting it on, but after a few seconds it settled into my skin. It wasn't the easiest to take off with micellar water, but it didn't take any scrubbing at all.Wear: It lasted all day! Comments: I'm a big fan of this concealer. You could tell I had makeup on – it's not exactly a natural look – but it didn't look odd or strange. However, their shade range is a bit of a let down, as there are only six and the darker shades wouldn't cover everyone.4/5amazon.co.uk

No7 Match Made Concealer, Cool Ivory7 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

No7 Match Made Concealer, Cool Ivory

Ease of use: Oh my gosh – what a revelation! This crayon concealer was ready to go straight away – one lick under the eyes and a dab in the corner, and I was ready to go. It barely needed patting in at all! Magic!Feel/Coverage: It's a medium coverage, but the shade was so natural against my skin that I could have gone out in just this and nothing else. Makeup-wise, of course.Wear: It pretty much stayed all day. I didn't feel the need to top up at all. It was also very easy to take off with micellar water.Comments: I am a BIG fan of this. If you can find a shade to match your skin, you're sorted! And with 25 shades to choose from, fingers crossed most people will be able to find a shade to suit them.5/5boots.com

Benefit Boi-ing Industrial Strength Concealer, 018 of 11
CREDIT: Closer Online

Benefit Boi-ing Industrial Strength Concealer, 01

Ease of use: If you're happy using your fingers to apply, there's no bother – but Benefit's Boi-ing concealer doesn't come with an applicator, so if you prefer using one, you'll have to invest in a concealer brush. Benefit doesn't stock one anymore, but MASQD has a fab one that's on offer at £4.50 currently.Feel/Coverage: I was a little apprehensive that it would be heavy as it's set in a pot, but once I touched it I could feel how smooth it was. A couple of dabs under my eyes and in the corner, and it was done! It's so easy to apply and the shade was perfect for me.Wear: It lasted all day and came off very easily with micellar water.Comments: I barely scratched the surface with this, so I can tell it's going to last me ages. I love how small the pot is as well, it would take hardly any room up in a handbag or makeup bag. However, there are only six shades which means I can't award it 5/5 – otherwise, I would have!4/5lookfantastic.com

Revolution Conceal and Define Concealer, C59 of 11
CREDIT: Revolution

Revolution Conceal and Define Concealer, C5

Ease of use: This handy sized concealer comes with a soft applicator, making it perfect to carry on-the-go. Revolution's applicator is smooth and soft, giving it a flawless application. Feel/Coverage: Although the consistency is thick, this concealer glides on smoothly, and is easy to blend out. However, it does oxidise slightly if you leave it a while before blending out - meaning the tone changes slightly, so be quick!Wear: This concealer instantly removed under dark under-eye circles, but sadly it didn't wear as well. Weep. The formula creased and wore off a little - so not great for hot summer days!Comments: It may not last a full, sweaty day in the office, but at just £4.00, this concealer is a total BARGAIN - and beauty bloggers have even hailed it the dupe for tarte Shape Tape. PLUS, it's available in a whopping 25 shades - so, there's quite literally one for everyone. 4/5beautybay.com

Smartere Secrets Cream Contour Concealer Express, Vanilla10 of 11

Smartere Secrets Cream Contour Concealer Express, Vanilla

Ease of use: Not only is this concealer available in 30ml which means it lasts for ages, the brush applicator is soft and easy to use. You will need a sponge or your fingers to blend.Feel/Coverage: The consistency is light and airy, but it covers like a dream. You could even use this to cover your whole face.Wear: As soon as it goes on, your eyes feel brighter and look more alive. It lasts well and doesn't fade during the day.Comments: At quite a high price, you might be put off, but to be honest, this concealer does more than just cover dark circles. It also decreases puffiness, reduces redness and fine lines, covers acne, scars and more. It can also be used to highlight and contour, is vegan and cruelty-free, and contains vitamin E to shield from environmental damage. We're impressed.4/5smarteresecretslondon.com

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer, Vanilla11 of 11
CREDIT: NARS

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer, Vanilla

Ease of use: This concealer has a spongey tip - always handy - and the long application stick means you can reach those awkward angles, without smudging the rest of your makeup. Feel/Coverage: NARS' cult-classic concealer hits those annoying dark circles, and any painful blemishes, without looking or feeling cakey. A little goes a long way with this hero product. Wear: It gets even better - NARS' creamy concealer will see you from day to night without rubbing off or fading away. This little saviour will make you look like you've had a full night's sleep, even at the end of a long day. Comments: Ok, ok, we know it's a little pricey at £24, but bear with us on this one... NARS' creamy concealer is a beauty cult-classic and there's a reason it's loved by so many. The creamy formula is oh-so-versatile, meaning you can use it under eyes, on spots or even to correct make-up errors. And it lasts a long time, too - one of these little tubes will keep you going for months. With 18 shades to choose from, it's pretty inclusive, too.5/5lookfantastic.com

WATCH: Closer Online's review of the best high street under eye concealers

Have you ever tried any of these concealers? Which was your favourite? Do you think we've missed any off? Let us know over on Facebook and Twitter.

What to read next:

Finding the perfect foundation for darker skin tones

Gel nails: How to do it at home – and which are the best high street brands?

You NEED to pack these 11 affordable festival beauty products

Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website, we never allow this to influence product selections - read why you should trust us